You're right and that is why under those circumstances I put the word voluntary in front of wealth redistribution.
If it's voluntary then it is not what we are talking about MANDATORY GOVERNMENT SPONSORED WEALTH REDISTRIBUTION - against my wishes. Taking my money and giving it to people that I do not think deserve it.
if Charity was mandatory, THEN it would be government wealth redistribution.
using your messed-up logic, then paying taxes is really charity.. and therefore I should get a tax deduction for paying taxes as a charitable contribution.
shut up already - your statements are nonsensical.